RE: critique or criticism?


Hey Mark _ how are you doing, pal? Scottie Hamilton from the resistance conference in London last August.




--- On Sun 11/28, Mark Kelly < mgekelly@xxxxxxxxxxx > wrote:
From: Mark Kelly [mailto: mgekelly@xxxxxxxxxxx]
To: foucault@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Date: Mon, 29 Nov 2004 14:51:42 +1100
Subject: RE: critique or criticism?

KT:<br><br>1) there is a distinction in French between criticisme and critique, but <br>criticisme has such a specific meaning, and in any case I don't think <br>Foucault talks about it. Critique is basically the French word for <br>criticism, full stop.<br><br>2)pouvire is not a word. You mean pouvoir. We already discussed this at <br>length Kevin, Google search! The question you ask is not really to the <br>point. Foucault hardly talks about power in these works, and where he does <br>he hasn't developed the conecpt of power (pouvoir) he does later, so it's <br>really irrelevant whether he says pouvoir or puissance (both being common <br>French nouns, he quite possibly uses both at various times).<br><br>Mark<br><br>&gt;From: &quot;Kevin Turner&quot; &lt;k_turner@xxxxxxxxxxxxx&gt;<br>&gt;Reply-To: foucault@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx<br>&gt;To: &quot;Foucault List&quot; <br>&lt;foucault@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx&gt;<br>&gt;Subject: critique or criticism?<br>&gt;Date: Sun, 28 Nov 2004 15:29:21 -0000<br>&gt;<br>&gt;Hi all,<br>&gt;<br>&gt;I have two questions:<br>&gt;<br>&gt;1) Does Foucault make a distinction between &quot;critique&quot; and <br>&quot;criticism&quot;?<br>&gt;I know that the subtitle to 'Omnes et Singulatim' has been translated as<br>&gt;both '...Critique of Political Reason,' and '...Criticism of Political<br>&gt;Reason,' and I was wondering if there is, or should, be a difference. It <br>may<br>&gt;be a moot point, but Mitchell Dean does make something of the <br>distinction<br>&gt;between criticism and critique vis-a-vis Foucault in his Critical and<br>&gt;Effective Histories.<br>&gt;<br>&gt;2) Did Foucault always use the term &quot;pouvire&quot; for power - i.e. <br>did he use<br>&gt;the term pouvoir in Folie et déraison (Madness and Civilization), The <br>Birth<br>&gt;of the Clinic and The Order of Things, or did he use the word puissance <br>in<br>&gt;these text?<br>&gt;<br>&gt;Regards - Kevin<br>&gt;<br>&gt;<br>&gt;<br>&gt;<br>&gt;--<br>&gt;<br>&gt;Checked by AVG Anti-Virus.<br>&gt;Version

: 7.0.289 / Virus Database: 265.4.3 - Release Date: 26/11/2004<br>&gt;<br><br><br>

_______________________________________________
Join Excite! - http://www.excite.com
The most personalized portal on the Web!

Partial thread listing: