Re: postone

On Mon, 10 Nov 1997 23:12:05 -0500 (EST), John Ransom wrote:
>I take Postone (based on what I've read and the useful comments from Steve
>and David) to be arguing that we need to separate Marx's own critique of
>capital as a system from the less essential issue of whether or not the
>proletariat is the primary critical force in capitalist society.

perhaps one can define Postone's critique (based on the intro. ) as
substantive as well as methodological. If Postone is right it means that
Marx doesn't agree with Hegel on the fundamentality of labor to human
self-consciousness and autonomy, which indeed moves him closer to Nietzsche
as Devid suggested. But I'm not sure how close and what this implies in terms
of utopia and politics.

Partial thread listing: